| # | Fencer | Score | Score | Fencer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nick Brandenburg | 0 | 5 | James Altschul |
| 2 | Shawn Hughes | 5 | 3 | Clay Elscott |
| 3 | Brady Joyce | 1 | 5 | Adrian Rivera |
| 4 | Shawn Hughes | 0 | 5 | James Altschul |
| 5 | Nick Brandenburg | 4 | 5 | Adrian Rivera |
| 6 | Brady Joyce | 5 | 1 | Clay Elscott |
| 7 | Shawn Hughes | 5 | 3 | Adrian Rivera |
| 8 | Brady Joyce | 3 | 5 | James Altschul |
| 9 | Nick Brandenburg | 4 | 5 | Clay Elscott |